How the score works (the parts that matter for appeals)
- SPS = product satisfaction + logistics + customer service, each with its own weight. Your SPS page shows the weights. Score × weight tells you where the points are.
- Each product is scored on its own over 90 days and ranked against products in its category and price band. One best-seller with a few bad orders can sink the shop.
- Paused or deleted products still count. 5-star reviews don't cancel out bad ones.
- An order with a pending appeal still counts until the appeal is approved.
The rule behind most failed appeals: who ships decides who's at fault.
| Return reason | Seller shipping (your own / Printify labels) | TikTok Shipping |
|---|---|---|
| Not received, arrived late | Counts against you | TikTok's, if you dispatched on time |
| Damaged, missing item, defective, not as described, wrong item | Counts against you | Counts against you |
| Doesn't fit, too big, too small, no longer needed | Buyer fault. Doesn't count. | |
Decision table: should you appeal this order?
Only appeal what a screenshot proves. You get 3 tries per order per metric, so the first try needs your best evidence. File one order per appeal: orders filed together are approved or rejected together.
| What happened | Call | Appeal reason to pick | What proves it |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Missing item" on a one-item order that was delivered | Appeal | Inaccurate Customer Selected Reason | Order detail showing qty 1 + delivery scan |
| "Missing item", but every package on the order shows the same tracking number, delivered | Appeal | Inaccurate Customer Selected Reason | Each package tab with the same number + delivery scan |
| "Not received", but the carrier shows delivered and signed | Appeal | Inaccurate Customer Selected Reason | Carrier delivery scan on or before the estimate |
| "Arrived too late", but it was delivered before the order's "Late delivery after…" time | Appeal | Inaccurate Customer Selected Reason | That line on the order + the delivery time |
| Fit or wrong size, filed as "defective" or "not as described" | Only with the buyer's OK | Inaccurate Customer Selected Reason | A chat where the buyer agrees it was fit or their pick. The buyer's return note alone gets rejected. |
| 1–2 star review that's abusive, about something else, or the buyer changed it | Appeal | Malicious Reviews / Customer Adjusted or Deleted | The review screenshot, plus the change if there was one |
| One order with a huge transit time, lost after pickup | Only with carrier proof | Delayed transit > Lost packages or returned to shipper | A written trace or loss letter from the carrier or your print provider. A "label created" screen gets rejected. |
| Weather, natural disaster, TikTok system outage | Appeal | Logistics Issues (or the matching transit reason) | Tracking showing the delay + the news or TikTok notice |
| Truly lost by the carrier, on seller shipping | Don't appeal | n/a | Counts against you by policy. Get your money back from the print provider. |
| Really broken, misprinted, or wrong item sent | Don't appeal | n/a | Fix with your print provider using the buyer's photo |
| Honest 1–2 star review about fit or quality | Don't appeal | n/a | It drops off about 90 days after delivery |
Evidence kit and steps
Attach for every order
- Order detail: SKU, size, color, qty, ship date, status history. Hide the buyer's name and address before the screenshot.
- Carrier tracking from the order page, plus the carrier's own site when it shows more.
- The return reason exactly as TikTok shows it, and the buyer's own words.
- Refund status: issued, auto-approved, or none. "No refund issued" helps your case.
- When it applies: listing proof (size chart, "sold separately" image), the review, a carrier or provider loss letter.
Every sentence in the appeal needs a screenshot behind it. Limits: 10,000 characters, up to 10 files (JPG, PNG, MP4, MOV, PDF), 5 MB each.
Steps
- Read your SPS page and find the weakest part (score × weight).
- Open that part and list each order counted against you.
- Sort each order with the decision table.
- Screenshot the evidence kit for each order you'll appeal.
- File: Account health > Shop Performance Score > Appeal center > Add new appeal. One order per appeal.
- Track the appeal ID. Results took 1–9 days in our case; the score updates about a day after "approved".
- Rejected? Read the reason. Retry only with new evidence that answers it.
- Escalate: support chat (ask for the ticket number) > your account manager with appeal IDs + ticket number > ask them about an internal NBFR review using the sheet below.
The order sheet your account manager will ask for
One row per order. The two grey rows are a made-up example store showing how to fill it in. Click any cell to type, add your own rows, then copy it straight into Excel or Google Sheets. Number your screenshots and list those numbers in the last column.
| # | Order ID | Product ID | Product | SKU ID(s) counted | Rows counted | Order date | TikTok return / refund reason | Buyer's own words | What the records show | Refund issued? | Carrier / tracking | Delivered (carrier scan) | Appeal ID | Evidence images |
|---|
Templates
Your name and store fill in from the top of the page. Swap the highlighted parts for your order's details, and cut any sentence you can't back with a screenshot.